119–43
.735 · RS 855 / RA 600 · Σ 94.7 WAR
CFAaron Judge10.9
LFCarl Yastrzemski12.4
RFStan Musial11.3
SSHonus Wagner11.5
2BJoe Morgan11.0
3BGeorge Brett9.4
1BAlbert Pujols9.7
PPete Alexander12.7
CMike Piazza8.7
DHEdgar Martinez7.0
SPSteve Carlton12.5
RPMark Eichhorn7.3
| Pos | Player | Peak | Era · Team | Peak line | WAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| C | Mike Piazza | 1997 | Steroid · Los Angeles Dodgers | 185 OPS+ · .362/.431/.638 · 40 HR | 8.7 |
| 1B | Albert Pujols | 2009 | Modern · St. Louis Cardinals | 189 OPS+ · .327/.443/.658 · 47 HR | 9.7 |
| 2B | Joe Morgan | 1975 | Expansion · Cincinnati Reds | 169 OPS+ · .327/.466/.508 · 17 HR · 67 SB | 11.0 |
| 3B | George Brett | 1980 | Free Agency · Kansas City Royals | 203 OPS+ · .390/.454/.664 · 24 HR | 9.4 |
| SS | Honus Wagner | 1908 | Deadball · Pittsburgh Pirates | 205 OPS+ · .354/.415/.542 · 10 HR · 53 SB | 11.5 |
| LF | Carl Yastrzemski | 1967 | Expansion · Boston Red Sox | 193 OPS+ · .326/.418/.622 · 44 HR | 12.4 |
| CF | Aaron Judge | 2024 | Modern · New York Yankees | 225 OPS+ · .322/.458/.701 · 58 HR | 10.9 |
| RF | Stan Musial | 1948 | Integration · St. Louis Cardinals | 200 OPS+ · .376/.450/.702 · 39 HR | 11.3 |
| DH | Edgar Martinez | 1995 | Steroid · Seattle Mariners | 185 OPS+ · .356/.479/.628 · 29 HR | 7.0 |
| SP | Pete Alexander | 1920 | Liveball · Chicago Cubs | 166 ERA+ · 27-14 · 1.91 ERA · 2.51 FIP | 12.7 |
| SP | Steve Carlton | 1972 | Expansion · Philadelphia Phillies | 182 ERA+ · 27-10 · 1.98 ERA · 2.14 FIP | 12.5 |
| RP | Mark Eichhorn | 1986 | Free Agency · Toronto Blue Jays | 246 ERA+ · 14-6 · 1.72 ERA · 2.33 FIP | 7.3 |